Going to the Wars |
 |
 click here for more details, find new or used items |
Max Hastings
|
|
Pages: 416 (Paperback)
ISBN: 0330377108
Pub: Pan Books
Pub date: 2001-04-06
Amazon.co.uk Sales Rank: 89536
Editorial Review:
Now that the Editor of the Evening Standard writes in his own paper on such things as his bewilderment in accompanying his daughter to a fashionable London club, it's possible to forget how well he wrote from the Falklands War almost 20 years ago. The South Atlantic coverage was his finest hour, his brilliant essays of description, motion and analysis. The Falklands chapters are the best in Going to the Wars, an account of the 15 years from 1967 when Hastings criss-crossed the globe on behalf of the Evening Standard and the BBC, taking pleasure in adventure, scoops and big picture bylines in trouble spots such as Northern Ireland, Biafra, Vietnam, Cambodia, the Middle East, Cyprus, Rhodesia and India. For one who protests constantly about his own cowardice and physical competence, he is remarkably brave when it comes to finding a story, whether it's in Northern Ireland, Biafra or Israel. Hastings is, of course, driven and egocentric, as a star reporter has to be. His is a story of traditional journalism, where the horror of a foreign battlefield is nothing compared with the fear of being scooped. He favourably compares British reporting standards with American: "British journalism remains rooted in a literary, rather than a political science, tradition, which helps to explain why it produces more and better jokes, if also more shameless fantasists." Max has never been known for his jokes, but his self-deprecation is certainly prodigious. --Kim Fletcher.
Reader Reviews:
A good book, but is it really candid? (3/4 people found this helpful)
Max Hastings portrays himself in this book as self-deprecating and candid.
In a sense he is when writing, but I couldn't help feeling there was an element of charade here. Hastings describes how he wasn't up to much as a soldier doing national service. But he gives no explanation of how he managed to cover the race riots in America as his first journalistic assignment. The most likely explanation is that he was helped by his parents' connections, but he appears not even to acknowledge this or explain his good fortune.
Also, you can't help noticing the point at which he contemplates marooning a friend and fellow reporter, so he can be first with the story.
He often says what he did, but hides how he managed to do it. For example, just how did he become friendly with SAS commander Michael Rose in the Falklands? He doesn't say. Again, you wonder if he is candid when it suits him, but hides his ruthless streak.
Such things make it harder to like the author, and as such make it harder to enjoy what is otherwise an excellent book.
Entertaining and informative (10/12 people found this helpful)
Principally writing this in response to an earlier review which criticises the book for being firstly too pro-war and secondly being too lightweight.
I disagree on both counts.
As to the first, the book is not pro-war, but rather pro-soldier: it is the courage, fortitude and skill of the soldiers rather than individual wars or the notion of war which attract Hastings' praise.
As to the second, the book is autobiography, not military or political history. Therefore the charge that it is lightweight is simply misconceived. In any event, as an introduction to various conflicts the book is highly informative- particularly those chapters dealing with the Israeli/Arab wars.
All in all, a very good read.
Fascinating throughout, a worthwhile read. (2/6 people found this helpful)
Hastings, despite his continual protestations of cowardice displays no little courage and sensetivity when handling difficult situations. His candid self assessment is refreshing and he attempts to give a balanced account of war as he has experienced it. His clear respect for many of the men and women he encountered and his ability to smile at his, and their frailties is one of the most charming aspects of this book. As well as providing us with a timely reminder of the men and women who bring us our daily quota of headlines this is an entertaining read full of character and characters, well worth the effort.
A worthwhile and absorbing read. (3/5 people found this helpful)
Max Hastings provides us with a book that moves between biography and comment on the times he has been at the front end of conflicts as a reporter. In an account he openly admits to his own personal failings whilst conveying (in a non-heroic fashion) his triumphs as he reports from various war zones. At times the book shows his adventurous nature in chasing the "scoop" but never at the expense of those who fought in the various battles. He is quick to understand the participants and tries to convey their will and mentality to be in the wars. Hastings may have been perceived as being arrogant but often this appears tingled with jealously for a man who reported from the front line of many of the late 20th Century wars. Hastings achieved much in an era without mobile communications, he was clearly a talent individual who used every resource available to tell the story to the public. A worthwhile and absorbing read.
A candid and refreshing work (3/4 people found this helpful)
This book is a very enjoyable book detailing the career of a great reporter. The honest admission by the author of his own cowardice and failure in the paratroop regiment is all the more striking when set alongside his reporting from some of the most dangerous locations of the last 30 years. Max Hastings doesn't attempt to hide his arrogance, vanity or ruthless pursuit of the front page, yet his honesty is refreshing in a genre in which 99% of works published are essays in self justification. The book is not a history book, if it sounds "jingoistic" in the chapters covering the Falklands it must be remembered that as a part of the task force he was subject to the emotions of taking part in a military campaign, it would be a very special man who could remain detached from national sentiment when part of a task force from their home country. The authors book about that war with Simon Jenkins is recognised as a very balanced and even account of the war which is not at all partisan or jingoistic in it's views. Hastings has some very pertinent views on the role of the war reporter, ultimately, while he may not paint a portrait of a likeable personality at times, it is a story of a great writer and journalist.
Similar Products
Nemesis: The Battle for Japan, 1944-45
Warriors: Extraordinary Tales from the Battlefield
Armageddon: The Battle for Germany 1944-45
Editor: An Inside Story of Newspapers
The Korean War (Pan Grand Strategy)
Categories
Amazon.co.uk places this book into the following categories:
Books -> Subjects -> Biography -> General AAS
Books -> Subjects -> Business, Finance & Law -> General AAS
Books -> Refinements -> Language (feature_browse-bin) -> English
Books -> Refinements -> Age (feature_two_browse-bin)
Books -> Refinements -> Format (binding_browse-bin) -> Paperback
Books -> Refinements -> Condition (condition-type)