The Macmillan Diaries: Cabinet Years 1950-1957

click here for more details, find new or used items	Harold Macmillan Used from £45.00 Pages: 704 (Paperback) Editor: Peter Catterall ISBN: 0330488686 Pub: Pan Books Pub date: 2004-03-05 Amazon.co.uk Sales Rank: 138702

Reader Reviews:

Machiavelli's student (0/0 people found this helpful)

Harold Macmillan is a curious figure, a self-conciously Edwardian grandee who led Britain into the modern era. In many ways he was an anachronism, a Prime Minister increasingly out of touch with the ways of modern life and regularly pilloried by the satirists for his complacency, his patrician outlook and his aristocratic, doddering mannerisms.

Yet at the time he wrote these diaries all this was in the future. Churchill was sliding into his dotage, his remaining energies spent on depriving Eden of the supreme office, apparently for his own mischievous amusement. When the old man finally left the stage, helped on his way by Cabinet dissent and a push from Macmillan himself, Eden soon wrecked himself on the rocks of Suez. Macmillan, clambering up the greasy pole with startling agility, witnessed it all from within the inner circle and faithfully recorded his thoughts. As Catteral states, one increasingly gets the impression that by 1955, with the Premiership conceivably within his grasp, Macmillan was writing for posterity.

He was right to be worried for his reputation. The Macmillan who emerges in these pages is a somewhat unattractive figure, slithering around Whitehall and Westminster in a manner that would have done Machiavelli proud. Alternately self-pitying and full of bravado, Macmillan passes the most scathing comments on his colleagues. Churchill is effectively senile, Eden little better than an hysterical schoolgirl. The lesser members of the Cabinet fare even worse. These diaries do not, at least in the earlier pages, suffer from discretion. Mingled with slashing personal judgements are acute political observations and the occassional revealing comment about his tortured family life.

In this volume is Macmillan in his own words. Only occassionally does the tortured bon viveur descends to banalities. But this is an accurate reflection of the man; a rather ordinary individual with a streak of brilliance and a remarkable talent for flashy self-promotion. Buy this book if you even remotely interested in this seminal period of British history.

Plus ca change (1/1 people found this helpful)

I wish more journalists would read these diaries. They might see modern events in greater perspective. The Blair/Brown nexus pales into insignificance when you read about Churchill and Eden. The golden age of politics never really existed. In 1955 Macmillan refers to "machines for both sides are in control and any struggle is within parties, rather than between them." In May 1956 he refers to a paper on reform of the house of Lords. The lead up to the Suez business, particularly the role of the UN is a preview of Iraq. These are not dry, self justifying diaries. They are written with a waspish wit and in a wonderful style fuelled by Macmillan's prodigous reading. I cannot recommend them too highly.

Similar Products

The Guardsmen: Harold Macmillan, Three Friends and the World They Made

Eden: The Life and Times of Anthony Eden, First Earl of Avon, 1897-1977

The Blair Years

Harold MacMillan: 1957-1986: Volume 2: 1957-86 v. 2

Never Again: Britain 1945-1951

Categories

Amazon.co.uk places this book into the following categories: